Welcome to Goodfella's Pizza LLC, a gem nestled in the heart of Wabash, Indiana, located at 1118 Stitt St. This local favorite is where tradition meets innovation, offering a remarkable selection of pizzas, pastas, and more that are sure to delight your taste buds.

Our menu showcases a variety of options that cater to all palates. Reviewers rave about our standout dishes, particularly the pizza sauce, pasta, and renowned cheesy garlic bread. Customer Bianca Sedano calls our pasta "absolutely outstanding," while another patron mentions that our pizza has a "light crispy crust" that sets it apart from the usual fare. Each bite is a celebration of flavor, reflecting our commitment to quality and presentation.

At Goodfella's, we pride ourselves on delivering fantastic value. As noted by B M, our specials change daily, ensuring that there's something new and exciting for everyone. From casual weeknight meals to special occasions, our food brings people together, making us a go-to choice in the community.

Speedy service is another hallmark of our establishment. Customers frequently mention our efficient, friendly staff who focus on making your experience enjoyable. As D G points out, we offer gluten-free options, underscoring our dedication to inclusivity in dining. Your order is ready as promised – just like Angel Clement's experience of having their pizza ready in just 15 minutes.

So whether you’re looking to indulge in our signature pies or sample our delectable sides, Goodfella's Pizza LLC is the place to be. With a welcoming atmosphere and consistently excellent food, it’s clear that we are more than just a pizza place; we are a hub for delicious, hearty meals and friendly encounters. Come and discover your new favorite spot today!

For more information, or to explore our enticing menu, please call us at +1 260-569-1162 or visit our website. We can’t wait to serve you!